Supreme Court Upholds IPR Constitutionality, Finds All Challenged Claims Must Be Reviewed

April 2018

The United States Supreme Court issued its much-anticipated ruling today, April 24, 2018, in Oil States Energy Services, LLC v. Greene’s Energy Group, LLC that challenged the constitutionality of inter partes review (IPR) proceedings created by Congress in the 2011 America Invents Act (AIA), under which issued patents may be cancelled by the Patent Office without a trial in a District Court. In a 7-2 decision authored by Justice Thomas, the Supreme Court upheld the constitutionality of these procedures, with Justices Gorsuch and Roberts dissenting.

The AIA created a number of new administrative trial procedures to address what parties contend may be invalid patents. Under these procedures, third parties may petition the Patent Office to cancel a patent on grounds that there exists prior art proving that the patent never should have been granted in the first place. These procedures take place before an administrative panel, the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB), not a court. In Oil States, a patent was invalidated using one of these procedures, inter partes review, and Oil States appealed, arguing that patents are private property and cannot be taken away by an administrative agency, but only by a court before a jury.

The majority disagreed, noting that the federal judiciary has long distinguished between “public rights” and “private rights,” and “public rights” may be adjudicated by an executive agency without a determination from the judiciary branch of government. Finding that the decision to grant a patent is a matter arising between the government and those subject to its authority, the majority in Oil States concluded that the decision to revoke a patent likewise “falls squarely within the public rights” doctrine. This in turn means that a court is not required to invalidate an issued patent, and the administrative procedures enacted by Congress and delegated to the Executive may be used by the Patent Office for that purpose.

Justice Gorsuch, joined by Justice Roberts, authored a dissenting opinion, arguing that because the Patent Office is not staffed by independent judges, but rather political appointees who serve at the pleasure of the President, the AIA procedures violate the constitutional guarantee of an independent judge.

In a separate case, SAS Institute Inc. v. Iancu, Director, the Supreme Court also ruled that if AIA review of a patent is granted, the PTAB is required to rule on the validity of all challenged patent claims.

Firm Highlights
Client Alert

Temporary COBRA Changes Under the American Rescue Plan Act

More
News

Kansas City Office of Lewis Rice Names New Member

More
News

Jeremy P. Brummond’s Article on Waivers of Consequential Damages is Published in Construction Executive

More
News

Brian P. Pezza Gives Advice on Vaccination Acceptance in the Workforce in Society for Human Resource Management Article

More
Diversity & Inclusion

Two Lewis Rice Members Selected for Leadership Council on Legal Diversity Programs

More
News

Lindsay S. C. Brinton and Meghan S. Largent Negotiate $1.4 Million Settlement for Landowners along Legacy Trail

More
Client Alert

Virginia Passes Sweeping Data Privacy Legislation Similar to CCPA and GDPR

More
News

Brian P. Pezza Discusses Vaccination Considerations for Employees in Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM) Article

More
Client Alert

Supreme Court Decision Provides Good News for Creditors

More
Diversity & Inclusion

Fatima G. Khan Elected President of South Asian Bar Association of Metropolitan St. Louis

More
Diversity & Inclusion

Lewis Rice Member Ronald A. Norwood Serves on Missouri Bar’s Special Committee on Lawyers of Color to Establish Diversity, Inclusion Programs

More
Client Alert

COVID-19 Rescue Plan Act Expands Paid Leave Availability but Does Not Revive Employer Mandates

More
News

David W. Sweeney Interviewed in Realtime REALTOR® Podcast on Changes to Elections in the City of St. Louis

More
Client Alert

New York State Regulator Discourages Ransomware Payments and Publishes New Cyber Insurance Risk Framework

More
Client Alert

City of St. Louis 2021 Primary Municipal Election: Meet the Candidates

More
News

Paul R. Himmelstein Joins Lewis Rice Kansas City Office

More
News

Meghan S. Largent and Lindsay S. C. Brinton Negotiate $700,000 Award to Cobb County, Georgia Landowners in Rails-to-Trails Case

More
News

Lewis Rice Wins Significant Victory for Atlanta Landowners Impacted by the Belt Line Rail-Trail

More
Client Alert

Have You Done Your Annual CCPA Housekeeping?

More
News

Jerina D. Phillips Offers COVID-19 Vaccination Advice for Employers in St. Louis Magazine Article

More